Would 'Cheryl Tweedy' have been as sucessful as 'Cheryl Cole'?.

If Cheryl Cole hadn't married a footballer and spent millions of pound's making herself look beautiful, would she have been as sucessful?.
My thinking is no. She was some chav council estate girl who likes to assualt people in toilets, and has "limited" talents.
I dont think Cheryl Tweedy would have been asked to judge on the X Factor, or have a solo career or be the "nation's sweetheart".
I think Cheryl Tweedy's career would have dried up once 'Girls Aloud' ended.